Revisiting sources of knowledge, subjectivity and authenticity on Wikipedia. Presented by Noopur Raval and Srikeit Tadepalli at CPOV: WikiWars conference held on 12th and 13th January 2010 in Bangalore, India
1. Wikipedia: site/s for knowledge production Revisiting sources of knowledge, subjectivity and authenticity Noopur Raval and Srikeit Tadepalli
2. Politics of knowledge production Critiquing notions of objectivity vs. subjectivity Recording subjective reality Wikipedia as the mainstream
3. Debating NPOV The paradox of NPOV Collective point of view/Critical point of view Unreal and dismissive approach
4. Position of an “insider outsider” The local expert Privileging knowledge based on geographical position of the user Going the Britannica way Wisdom of the expert/Wisdom of the masses
5. Questions of source Knowledge judged on where it comes from Judging validity of the information based on the seniority of the user Verifying the “unverifiable”
6. Wikipedia as a social repository Addressing the subaltern Fixing oral histories Does lived experience make information more comprehensive?
7. Conclusion Not a distant, “neutral” dump for knowledge Organic, active site of resistance Wikipedia, the complete (incomplete) encyclopedia